Adopt
Profiles around the world
A desk scan on 6 November 2026 of DCAT-based profiles at supranational, national and sector level, and of the UK sector standards a pan-UK profile must sit beside. Each was read for what it offers people who must comply: specification, validator, examples, machine-readable shapes and schema, quality scoring, converters, templates and extension mechanisms. It is not an audit: "Not seen" means it was not found in the scan and may exist. No ranking is claimed beyond what each source says itself.
The profiles scanned
| Profile | Scope | Area | What stands out | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DCAT-AP 3.0.1 | Supranational | European Union | The base of every European profile, with a family of sector extensions. | DCAT-AP 3.0.1V |
| data.europa.eu quality assessment | Supranational | European Union | Scores every harvested record on findability, accessibility, interoperability, reusability and contextuality. | data.europa.eu Metadata Quality AssessmentK |
| DCAT-US 3.0 | National | United States | JSON Schema and SHACL, an online validator, field-by-field references, an implementation guide and a migration route from version 1.1. | DCAT-US Schema v3.0S |
| DCAT-AP-NO | National | Norway | A showroom of examples, a Turtle template, a validator, a converter from OpenAPI to data service records and a quality vocabulary. | DCAT-AP-NO and the data.norge.no toolsS |
| DCAT-AP.de | National | Germany | Conventions that settle how to fill each property, not just whether. | DCAT-AP.deK |
| DCAT-AP-SE | National | Sweden | Plain-language guidance with examples per property. | DCAT-AP-SEK |
| DCAT-AP-NL 3.0 | National | Netherlands | Builds the high-value datasets rules into the national profile. | DCAT-AP-NL 3.0S |
| DCAT-AP_IT | National | Italy | Top of the EU metadata quality ranking in November 2025, by the national agency's own account. | DCAT-AP_ITS |
| DCAT-AP-ES | National | Spain | Tied to a legal interoperability standard, so conformance is an obligation. | DCAT-AP-ES (NTI-RISP)K |
| DCAT-AP-CH | National | Switzerland | Multilingual by design: German, French, Italian and English. | DCAT-AP-CH (eCH-0200)K |
| HealthDCAT-AP Release 7 | Sector | European Union | Population, record counts, coding systems and access bodies for health data. | HealthDCAT-AP Release 7S |
| GeoDCAT-AP 3.1.0 | Sector | European Union | Maps ISO 19115 and INSPIRE metadata to DCAT, with a long-standing conversion route. | GeoDCAT-AP 3.1.0S |
| MLDCAT-AP 3.x | Sector | European Union | Models, training data and evaluation, aligned with the EU AI Act. | MLDCAT-AP 3.0.0 and 3.1.0S |
| Dataspace Protocol | Sector | International | Every dataset offer carries an ODRL policy; contract negotiation follows from the catalogue. | Eclipse Dataspace ProtocolS |
| Croissant 1.1 | Sector | International | What machine learning tools read; adds provenance, usage policies and responsible AI properties. | Croissant 1.1S |
| UK GEMINI 2.3 | UK sector | United Kingdom | XML, with Schematron rules; MEDIN extends it for marine data. | UK GEMINI 2.3S |
| HDR UK Gateway schema | UK sector | United Kingdom | JSON Schema with a weighted completeness and error score, and a translation service between versions. | HDR UK Gateway schemataS |
| Ofgem Data Best Practice | UK sector | Great Britain | Principles rather than a schema: Dublin Core, presumed open and open data triage. | Data Best Practice GuidanceS |
| xGov MEM v0.1.0 | UK | United Kingdom | What DCAT-AP-UK evolves. | UK Cross-Government Metadata Exchange ModelV |
Compared like for like
DCAT-AP-UK’s own row is a self-assessment against the same columns, not an independent review.
| Profile | Specification | SHACL shapes | JSON Schema | Validator | Examples or showroom | Quality score | Converters or migration | Sector extensions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DCAT-AP 3.0.1 | Yes | Yes | Not seen | Yes | Yes | No | Not seen | Yes |
| data.europa.eu quality assessment | Partly | Partly | No | Partly | No | Yes | No | No |
| DCAT-US 3.0 | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Not seen | Yes | Not seen |
| DCAT-AP-NO | Yes | Yes | Not seen | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Partly |
| DCAT-AP.de | Yes | Yes | Not seen | Yes | Partly | Not seen | Not seen | Not seen |
| DCAT-AP-SE | Yes | Not seen | Not seen | Partly | Yes | Not seen | Not seen | Not seen |
| DCAT-AP-NL 3.0 | Yes | Partly | Not seen | Not seen | Partly | Not seen | Not seen | Yes |
| DCAT-AP_IT | Yes | Partly | Not seen | Yes | Partly | Yes | Not seen | Not seen |
| DCAT-AP-ES | Yes | Not seen | Not seen | Partly | Partly | Not seen | Not seen | Not seen |
| DCAT-AP-CH | Yes | Not seen | Not seen | Not seen | Partly | Not seen | Not seen | Not seen |
| HealthDCAT-AP Release 7 | Yes | Yes | Not seen | Not seen | Yes | Not seen | Not seen | No |
| GeoDCAT-AP 3.1.0 | Yes | Yes | Not seen | Yes | Yes | Not seen | Yes | No |
| MLDCAT-AP 3.x | Yes | Partly | Not seen | Not seen | Partly | Not seen | Not seen | No |
| Dataspace Protocol | Yes | Partly | Yes | Not seen | Yes | No | No | No |
| Croissant 1.1 | Yes | No | Not seen | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Partly |
| UK GEMINI 2.3 | Yes | No | No | Yes | Partly | Not seen | Not seen | Partly |
| HDR UK Gateway schema | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | Partly | Yes | Yes | No |
| Ofgem Data Best Practice | Partly | No | No | No | Partly | No | No | No |
| xGov MEM v0.1.0 | Yes | No | Partly | No | Partly | No | No | No |
| DCAT-AP-UK 1.1 (this profile) | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
What DCAT-AP-UK takes from them
A validator anyone can use without installing anything
Check records in the browser, nothing uploaded; the same verdict as the published SHACL and JSON Schema, proven on every build.
Learned from: DCAT-US 3.0, DCAT-AP-NO, DCAT-AP 3.0.1
A quality score people can act on
The five quality dimensions and their points, shown live in the record builder and the bulk checker, with what to add next.
Learned from: data.europa.eu quality assessment, HDR UK Gateway schema, DCAT-AP_IT
A showroom of complete examples
Worked examples for every kind of record and every extension, each passing three validators.
Learned from: DCAT-AP-NO, DCAT-AP-SE
Conventions that settle how to fill a property
Each property says what it is for, how it differs from its neighbours, and gives guidance and an example.
Learned from: DCAT-AP.de, DCAT-AP-SE
A converter from OpenAPI to a data service record
Paste an OpenAPI description; get a draft record, checked, with the gaps listed.
Learned from: DCAT-AP-NO
A migration route from the old model
xGov MEM records convert and are checked in one step, with notes on what changed.
Learned from: DCAT-US 3.0
Sector extensions on one base
Nine UK extensions that only raise obligations or add properties, each with its own shapes, schema, example and break.
Learned from: DCAT-AP 3.0.1, HealthDCAT-AP Release 7, GeoDCAT-AP 3.1.0, MLDCAT-AP 3.x
High-value datasets rules inside the national profile
An optional extension for exchange with EU catalogues, which creates no UK obligation.
Learned from: DCAT-AP-NL 3.0
Usage policies machines can read
ODRL policy templates, including whether data may train AI models, and a property that links them.
Learned from: Dataspace Protocol, Croissant 1.1
Field-by-field references and a spreadsheet route
A template with one row per dataset, and a bulk converter and checker in the browser.
Learned from: DCAT-US 3.0, HDR UK Gateway schema
Multilingual by design
Records carry every UK language. A Welsh portal is on the open register (O-07).
Learned from: DCAT-AP-CH
What the UK adds that the scan did not find elsewhere
- A critical data asset switch that turns on the extra properties the Data Asset Management Policy asks for, in the same record.
- The Government Security Classifications in every record, with SECRET and TOP SECRET kept out of OFFICIAL catalogues.
- Where data is held and sent, and the UK GDPR transfer safeguard, checked by a rule (R-08).
- Connection security for the post-quantum inventory, and warnings on weak checksums.
- Contact forms preferred over mailboxes, and never a named person.
- Three independent validators held to the same verdict on every example and every deliberate break.